4 Safe Edible Mushrooms for Foragers and Cheapskates

NOTE: I shouldn’t have to say this but I will, just in case a bureaucrat is reading: don’t go eating any mushrooms you’re not completely sure are safe. And don’t sue us if you get a stomachache. Do your own research on mushrooms. We’re just providing a few ideas to get you started.

At the end of summer, the rain and cooler weather did its work and a wide variety of beautiful mushrooms appeared across my food forest.

I counted over 30 species in one week… and had a realization: I knew almost nothing about identifying mushrooms.

Sure, I probably knew more than the average Joe. I knew that some fungi worked in harmony with trees to provide them with nutrients… I knew that many fungi were the primary decomposers of wood… I knew that mushrooms were just the fruiting body of a much larger, ofter perennial organism living beneath the soil.

But naming the mushrooms popping up around my yard? Impossible.

This hit me as rather pathetic. I know the names of many animals and insect and I’m an encyclopedia when it somes to plants – but mushrooms?

I think I could name 10, though I wouldn’t even be able to identify most of them by sight.

Back when I lived in Tennessee, I did eat puffball mushrooms, once I learned how to safely identify ones that were okay for the table.

Pretty sad for a prepper/wild forager/garden expert.

Seeing the many species erupt in my food forest gave me a new passion: to learn about fungi and to learn which ones I could safely eat.

After a few weeks of research, I’ve foraged around for some of the super-easy mushrooms for beginners and prepared them for my table.

I’m still here. Not poisoned a bit. And I haven’t eaten this good in a long time!

Since food is expensive and mushrooms are highly nutritious, I think it’s worth looking at some edible mushrooms even a beginner (like me) can pluck, identify and safely consume without worrying.

Let’s go picking.

Boletes

Boletes are easy to spot and stand out from other mushrooms because they lack gills.

Most mushrooms have gills that look like this:

MushroomGills

If you’re a beginning forager, the rule of thumb is AVOID mushrooms with gills.

Some non-gilled mushrooms can make you sick, yet none of them are likely to kill you. You might wish you were dead, but you wouldn’t be meeting St. Peter a few days after ingestion like you would if you accidentally ate some Destroying Angels.

Boletes have pores rather than gills on their undersides. Check this out:

MushroomPores

Boletes almost always grow beneath trees. In my neighborhood they love oaks. As a dried mushrooms they’re very hard to beat.

How do you know if you have an edible bolete? Here’s the way to stay (generally) safe from stomach upset: avoid boletes that stain blue when cut or bruised. Also avoid boletes that have red or yellow pores. I’ve followed this advice and have eaten three or four different species without any trouble. Some of them were really delicious and far surpassed the flavor of store mushrooms.

The best way to ensure complete bolete safety is to get a hold of a few mushroom guides and double-check what you find. If you’re really lucky you’ll discover some huge King boletes you can brag about.

Chanterelles

Unlike the meaty heftiness of boletes, chanterelles are delicate mushrooms with a marvelous fruity flavor that’s hard to pin down.

They also lack delicate gills but are a little tricky since they have tough ridges that run down their stems and look somewhat like standard mushroom gills. Most – but not all – chanterelles are bright yellow. They’re also a species that likes to hang around the roots of specific trees. I found these growing in a mixed pine and oak field behind my house:

Chanterelles2

 

Here’s one closer up:

Chanterelle

 

When you feel the ridges on a chanterelle they don’t crumble, unlike typical mushroom gills.

Again – make sure you have chanterelles. Some folks have gotten them mixed up with Jack-o-Lantern mushrooms and given themselves some horrid upset stomachs. Get to know what both look like. Once you find chanterelles – a really easy-to-identify edible mushroom – you’ll keep finding them easily. Once you eat them, you’ll also want more.

I’m going looking again this afternoon.

Puffballs

Puffballs are easy to identify as puffballs; it’s just hard to tell which species you have.

That’s okay since most puffballs are edible.

If you find one, cut it in half to make sure you didn’t pick the “button” stage of a gilled mushroom on accident. If it’s clear, white flesh all the way through, with no hint of gills or other structures, you’re good to go.

I had some for breakfast a few weeks ago and took a photo:

PuffballBreakfast

 

Puffballs have a mild flavor and are good with bacon. Everything’s good with bacon.

NOTE: if your puffball isn’t white inside, avoid it. It’s either past its prime or it could be a toxic relative. You want it nice and white all the way through.

Morels

Morels are a mushroom I can only dream about finding. Findinf morels in Florida is like finding honesty in D.C. – it’s so uncommon as to be not worth the hunt.

Fortunately, Florida aside, much of the country is blessed with these gourmet edibles in the spring. They like recently burned areas and old orchards, but you can find them in a lot of woodlands too. They’re also hard to mistake for anything else other than morels:

3613970402_f68f1f16d8_z

Photo credit Rebecca Siegel

Since I haven’t actively hunted for these guys, I can’t tell you much about them; however, I did find a great article from Field and Stream that will get you started.

There’s food everywhere, folks – including lots of edible mushrooms.

Learn what you can eat now and you’ll be feasting when others are living on spam and rice.

About David The Good

David The Good is a naturalist, author and hard-core gardener who has grown his own food since 1984. At age five, he sprouted a bean in a Dixie cup of soil and caught the gardening bug. Soon after, his dad built an 8’ by 8’ plot for him and David hasn’t stopped growing since. David is the author of four books, writes a regular column for The Ag Mag in North Central Florida, is a Mother Earth News blogger and has also written for outlets including Backwoods Home, Survival Blog and Self-Reliance Magazine. You can find his books on Amazon here. David is a Christian, an artist, a husband, a father of seven, a cigar-smoker and an unrepentant economics junkie who now lives somewhere near the equator on a productive cocoa farm. Visit his daily gardening and survival blog here: The Survival Gardener And for lots more gardening info, click here and subscribe to his often hilarious YouTube channel.

View all posts by David The Good

One Response to “4 Safe Edible Mushrooms for Foragers and Cheapskates”

  1. D. Says:

    Great article, thanks! We found Morels in the spring in Nebraska by the river. I found one large Morel in my raised bed garden after a rainy spring! I will be looking for the others this spring.

    Reply

Leave a Reply